By Mary Langan, Founder, Nua Training
Picture a finance director preparing for her quarterly board update. She is bright, well prepared and knows her numbers better than anyone in the building. She runs through the presentation, twenty-two slides in twenty minutes, and does not put a foot wrong. I have met versions of her many times.
When she finishes, ask her what she wants the board to do. She pauses. “Note the position,” she says. Then, a little less sure, “and probably approve the revised forecast.”
Those are two different answers, and she knows it. The presentation she has built will leave the board noting a great deal and deciding nothing. I recognise that moment because I have seen it, in one form or another, with hundreds of senior people.
The Expertise Trap
The mistake is easy to state. Senior leaders present what they know, instead of what the audience needs in order to decide. I call it the expertise trap.
The presentation becomes a way of showing the work. Everything is accurate, everything is included, and it all appears in the order the leader discovered it. The audience is waiting for something much simpler. What does this mean for us, and what are you asking me to do?
You can usually spot it in the first two minutes. There is background, then context, then methodology. The point arrives late, or never quite arrives, and the audience has to assemble the conclusion for themselves. Some will. Others will reach a different one.
This is not about talking down to a senior audience. They are capable people. But capable people are also short on time, and they cannot take in a conclusion that has not yet been stated.
The cost is rarely a failed presentation. It is a deferred decision. “Let’s take this away and come back to it” is one of the most expensive sentences in a senior meeting, because it usually means the presentation did not do its job. The work has to be done again, with the same people, a month later.
Why Capable Leaders Fall Into It
It is not a failure of intelligence or effort. If anything, it is the opposite. The mistake is logical, which is exactly why it is so common. Three habits sit behind it.
Showing your working. At school and university, marks went to the people who showed their method. Many leaders carry that instinct into the boardroom without noticing.
Protecting yourself with data. In most organisations, nobody has been criticised for including too much. A full set of figures feels safe. If someone challenges you, the answer is already on the page.
Assuming a smart audience wants all the detail. In my experience, they want the reverse. They want someone to have done the thinking for them, so that they can spend their limited time on the decision.
There is also a simpler reason. Senior people reached their roles by knowing things. They were rewarded for knowledge and rarely for making things easy for other people. Deciding what to leave out is a separate skill, and almost nobody is taught it.
What It Looks Like in Practice
The details change, but the pattern is very consistent. These are three versions I see regularly.
The board update. A chief operating officer takes the board through forty minutes of programme status across six workstreams. The one decision she needs, extra budget for a single workstream, appears in the last five minutes, when the chair is already looking at the clock.
The executive team briefing. A head of sales walks the team through pipeline by region, by product and by quarter. Everything he says is correct. But he never says whether the quarter looks healthy, so each person leaves with a different view.
The investor presentation. A founder spends fifteen minutes explaining how the technology works. The investors have three simple questions: why this, why now and how big? The detail impresses them, but it does not answer any of those questions.
In each case, the audience was left to do the leader’s final piece of work, which was to work out what it all meant.
How to Tell If You Are Doing It
Most leaders in the trap do not feel they are in it. They feel thorough. A few signs give it away.
• Your opening slide is background, not a recommendation.
• You say “I will skip through this” more than once.
• Someone senior interrupts with “So what are you recommending?” before you have reached the end.
• You feel slightly relieved when nobody asks a question.
The last one is the most telling. If you are relieved, it is often because you were never sure the audience had understood the point.
What to Do Instead
The change is juts one prinicple. Decide what you want the audience to decide or do, and build the presentation backwards from there. If you are wondering how to present to the board, this is most of the answer. Here are three things to try before your next senior leader presentation.
1. Start with the question. Before you open any material, finish this sentence: “After this presentation, I want them to decide or do…” If the honest answer is that you want them to “know” something, ask yourself why. It is usually a decision in disguise.
2. Write the final slide first. If you cannot summarise your message in three lines, you do not yet know it well enough to present it. Everything else in the presentation then has to earn its place by supporting those three lines. The communications firm Duarte gives similar advice for this audience: lead with the bottom line and hold the supporting detail back for questions.
3. Test it on someone who does not know the subject. Give your material to a colleague from a different department and ask what questions they still have. Those questions are your gaps. If they cannot say what you are asking for, neither will your audience.
The objection I hear most is, “But what if they ask about something I have left out?” That is what your preparation and your appendix are for. A question about a detail you held back is a good sign. It means the room is engaged and the conversation is the one you wanted.
The other worry is looking thin. Leaders tell me that if they cut material, people will assume they have not done the work. In practice, it works the other way. A short, clear recommendation tells the room you have done the work and drawn a conclusion from it. A long tour of everything you looked at only tells them you have looked.
Presenting with confidence rarely comes from rehearsing your delivery harder. It comes from knowing exactly what you are asking for. This is why executive presentation skills are less about technique than people expect. A group course on presentation skills training can teach structure well. This particular habit, though, is often easier to change with someone watching you present.
Back to the Finance Director
Now imagine her update rebuilt around a single sentence: “I am asking the board to approve a revised forecast, and I will show you why in three points.” Twenty-two slides become six, and the rest go into an appendix.
The board spends its time discussing the decision, rather than trying to work out what the decision is. She has said less, yet she is far more in control of the room.
Nothing about her delivery needs to change. Her voice, pace and presence were already good. What changes is that she knows what she wants from the room before she walks into it.
If any of this sounds familiar, presentation coaching might be worth exploring. It is the kind of work we do in our presentation skills coaching sessions: finding the pattern in how you present, and changing it before the meeting that matters.